Review War: Delirium by Lauren Oliver and Giveaway

12 June, 2012 Giveaways, Review Wars 30 comments

Delirium by Lauren Oliver

Publisher: HarperTeen
Pages: 480 (Hardback)
Series: Delirium, #1

 

 

Before scientists found the cure, people thought love was a good thing. They didn’t understand that once love — the deliria — blooms in your blood, there is no escaping its hold. Things are different now. Scientists are able to eradicate love, and the government demands that all citizens receive the cure upon turning eighteen. Lena Holoway has always looked forward to the day when she’ll be cured. A life without love is a life without pain: safe, measured, predictable, and happy.

But with ninety-five days left until her treatment, Lena does the unthinkable: She falls in love.

The players

In one corner we have Cuddlebuggery’s own Grand Madam Queen Mis­tress of the Uni­verse, Kat Kennedy! And in the other corner we have first time guest to Cuddlebuggery, hailing from Wake Up at Seven, Princess of Darkness, Isabelle Doan!

I expect a nice and dirty fight, ladies. Hold no punches and take no prisoners!

Kat Kennedy:  This Kat Kennedy here with Isabelle Doan from Wake Up at Seven Blog and we’ll be discussing Delirium by Lauren Oliver today – or more importantly, why I thought Delirium was seriously flawed and why Izzy is WRONG.  Or, you know, on the opposite side of that argument…

Isabelle Doan:  I may be the underdog here, Kat, but Delirium was probably one of my favorite reads of 2012 so far.

Kat Kennedy:  I honestly can’t see why but I am at least willing to pretend to listen to your argument.  As far as Dystopians go – it would scarcely be rated among the best of them.

Isabelle Doan:  If you’re willing to pretend then I’ll join your imaginary playhouse. And to be honest, I can see why this wouldn’t be a great dystopian but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t a great novel.

Kat Kennedy:  I’m not wailing on Lauren Oliver – I have a lot of respect for her as an author but the world building was really weak and inconsistent for me.  And since it is very firmly a dystopian – I felt that was a let down.  Also – my imaginary playhouse is awesome.

Isabelle Doan:  I’ll agree to that, Kat. As I said in my review, these people still have ibuprofen when they have a freaking cure for love. However, the characters really helped to bring us into this inconsistent world, AS YOU SO CALL IT.

And your playhouse is a cardboard box.

Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos

Kat Kennedy:  MY PLAYHOUSE HAS ALCOHOL!

Isabelle Doan:  Well if it has manly alcohol, I’ll retract my statement.

Kat Kennedy: And that’s all that matters.  Look, the characters were okay.  I felt the main protagonist was nicely fleshed out but they’re not really enough for me to patch up the shaky world building.  Alex is very flimsy in his characterization.

Isabelle Doan:  Alex is maybe flimsy, but I feel that he has something good that will happen to him in Pandemonium. As you can see, he’s not revealing all of his secrets- yet. Perhaps Lauren Oliver is setting us up for an amazing second novel.  He’s a tortured character, and that’s good.

Kat Kennedy:  Oliver has writing chops – there is no doubt.  But I don’t think setting up for a second novel really excuses an awkward first one.  I will grant that he is a bit deeper than many male protagonists.  And I DID enjoy Lena though I felt her backstory was a bit of a copout on Oliver’s part.

Isabelle Doan:  What part of it did you think was awkward, Miss Kat?

Kat Kennedy:  Well, like I said, the world building was inconsistent, I didn’t think Alex was very well characterized and I think Oliver bit off more than she could chew in regards to the philosophical aspect of a society without love.  For me, it made for a vaguely unfulfilling, frustrating reading experience.

Isabelle Doan:  Vaguely unfulfilling? This isn’t a Twinkie, Kat! (Although I could go for one right now.)  And the philosophical part is interesting. No love doesn’t mean people are selfish, if that’s what you mean.

Kat Kennedy:  No, I mean in the nurturing department and people not by psychopaths.  But that’s kind of a lot to get into.  What did you think about the writing?  Did the language and the technique do it for you?

Isabelle Doan:  Well, I think Lauren Oliver is awesome with a pen, although the similes were too frequent, so it felt like I was just reading words on a page sometimes. If you ever get that feeling.  And sometimes they were awkward.

Kat Kennedy:  I get the feeling that I’m reading words on a page a lot.  Like, all the time.  Like, every time I crack open a book, BAM!  Words on a page.  Disgraceful….

Yeah, I generally have to agree – but I’m not going to complain much – she’s pretty proficient and she has a smooth style.

Isabelle Doan:  You have killed my pride. Prepare to die.

Kat Kennedy:  In a knife fight?

Isabelle Doan:  I was thinking more gouging your eyes out with rusty spoons, but that works too.

Kat Kennedy:  You should have those violent tendencies checked out.  Maybe your weren’t cuddled enough as a child.

WHICH BRINGS ME TO MY BIGGEST GRIPE!

I just don’t think Oliver realistically explored this concept of a loveless society.

Isabelle Doan:  The teenagers and children care for each other, though. As you can see, Lena cared for her little niece Gracie. So it’s not as if the children are completely devoid of love.

Kat Kennedy:  Yeah, but that’s the thing – we have no real basis to fall on because Lena was raised by a nurturing, loving mother.  And her entire family is filled with sympathizers.

What about a child that experiences no love?  Anywhere.  From anyone?

Because children don’t necessarily make good primary caregivers and solid attachments for other children.

Isabelle Doan:  If I’m not mistaken, Hana was one of those children. Which is why she’s such a maverick when it comes to see what’s on the other side. Literally, and figuratively.

Kat Kennedy:  But that’s the thing – she’s completely normal.  I wonder if Oliver truly understand attachment or not.  I don’t know if she has kids.

But there wasn’t any exploration of the psychological effects of that kind of childhood.

And I don’t buy that “normal” is the status quo.

Isabelle Doan:  Okay, so maybe normal isn’t the status quo. But maybe the effects of “not being cuddled enough” are?

Kat Kennedy:  Well, I don’t know.  On a scale of 1-10 how psychopathic are you?

Isabelle Doan:  Well if one is, trips people on the street and ten is being like one of those zombie cannibals on bath salts – I would have to say 4.

Kat Kennedy:  You threatened to cut my eyes out with a rusty spoon! A five at least.

Isabelle Doan:  I won’t go higher than six. Six is creating 27 accounts on goodreads to harass other authors and promote my book.

Kat Kennedy:  Oh my goodness.  You just went there.

Okay, I think this wraps up that discussion!  I will be reading Pandemonium though to see if you’re right about it!

If not, I’m coming back to get you!

Isabelle Doan:  Yes ma’am. But not if the zombie cannibals get you first.

Kat Kennedy:  Damn those zombie cannibals!

Kat’s review | Isabelle’s review

What did you think?  Who’s right and who’s wrong?
Want to par­tic­i­pate in a review war?  Pick a book, pick Stephanie or Kat and con­tact us!

 

Giveaway

We are giving away one signed copy of Delirium by Lauren Oliver! And dont foget to stop over at Wake Up at Seven to enter for your chance to win a signed copy of Pandemonium!

 

Contest Rules:

  • To enter, please fill out the Raffelcopter form below.
  • We ask that all entrants be at least 13 years or older to enter.
  • The giveaway is open to everyone, US and international!
  • When the winners are chosen, it will be announced here and the winners will be emailed. Please check your email because we are only giving the winner 48 hours to respond! Otherwise another winner will have to be selected.
  • Please enter your email address in the Rafflecopter form and not the comments!
  • Also, please understand that we reserve the right to disqualify any entries we find gaming the system. Cheaters never prosper!

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Kat Kennedy

Kat Kennedy

Co-blogger at Cuddlebuggery
Kat Kennedy is a book reviewer and aspiring author in the Young Adult genre. She reviews critically but humorously and get super excited about great books. Find her on GoodReads.
Kat Kennedy
I'm supposed to have a crochet date where I chill and crochet but hahahaha overlay crochet and chill? Will never happen. - 9 hours ago
Kat Kennedy
Kat Kennedy

Latest posts by Kat Kennedy (see all)


30 Responses to “Review War: Delirium by Lauren Oliver and Giveaway”

  1. Kelsey @ Slush Sleuth

    I’m absolutely on team Kat here. Delirium was my MOST disappointing read last year. I almost never stop a series midway through, but unless you come back screaming Pandemonium praises, I think I’m out. The only people in the book I didn’t hate were Hannah and Grace (and I still kind of hated them).

    I’ll be interested to hear what you have to say about Pandemonium though, Kat.
    Kelsey @ Slush Sleuth recently posted…Top Ten Tuesday: Top Ten Beach Books!My Profile

  2. Lexie B.

    Okay, first off, I HAVE MISSED THESE. And Isabelle was a fabulous warrer!

    Regarding the book itself, however, I definitely have to side with Kat. Honestly, the only thing I liked about the entire book was the writing, and even that grew a bit too purple for me. The world-building was completely nonsensical and unexplored, I loathed the main character and wished it had been told from Hana’s point of view, the plot was painfully slow and almost nonexistent, and I never really felt the romance, though I liked Alex.

    So, yeah, I was not too crazy about this one. 😛
    Lexie B. recently posted…The Makings of a FavoriteMy Profile

      • Lexie B.

        @Isabelle Doan: I AM SIMPLY BEING HONEST. I mean, with the Troy gifs and the Yoda graphic . . . one just can’t go wrong.

        But yeah, Lena grated on me because she was one of those protagonists who is constantly whinging about how plain and unlikable they are, how much lovelier and more awesome everyone around them must be, and how they can only feel good about themselves when a boy is around. I . . . am not a fan of those protagonists.
        Lexie B. recently posted…The Makings of a FavoriteMy Profile

  3. JBH

    I’m with Kat on this one. In my one entire semester of sociology in college, I remember there being an experiment that showed babies who had their basic needs promptly taken care of, but were shown no real affection, were more likely to die than babies that were loved. (I don’t know who conducts such a horrible experiment, but that chapter on love in society really stuck with me.) That was just the chapter on babies. There’s an entire field that studies the effects of emotion on our society and people.

  4. Emily (Ed and Em's Reviews)

    I literally almost cried as the read this. The fact that zombies on bath salts are mentioned… Can you imagine that? I’m laughing so hard just thinking about it.
    Also Isabelle, thanks for working in that comment about the idiot from Goodreads. Out loud I said, “BURNNNNN.” And then my boyfriend asked why I talk to myself all the time. So thank you.

    I can’t pick sides because alas, I have not yet read the book… but the cover is pretty…
    Emily (Ed and Em’s Reviews) recently posted…Top Ten Tuesday (14)My Profile

  5. Annabelle

    It feels like it’s been forever since I’ve read a review was, and I’ve missed them! I haven’t read Delirium yet, but I’ve heard mixed things about it, so we’ll see how it goes.
    Annabelle recently posted…Dreamless GIVEAWAY!My Profile

  6. Amy @ Turn the Page

    I also kind of wish Delirium had been written from Hana’s point of view. I do like Lauren Oliver’s writing, but, yeah, I didn’t love this as much as a lot of people did.

    Pandemonium was a let down and really I think the main problem is with the protagonist. I think I said in my review, she seems to constantly need to have someone there telling her what to do, she hasn’t got any drive or determination of her own.

    But I expect I will finish the series off, just to see how it ends.
    Amy @ Turn the Page recently posted…One Year Blogoversary Winner!My Profile

  7. Mari - Escape In A Book
    Twitter:

    You put up a good fight, Kat, but I’m with Isabelle on this one! That being said I thought you made an interesting point about children and their need for love and being near someone. I’ve learned that children wither away without love and I’ve read somewhere that, sadly, that can be the case in some orphanages in very poor places. It breaks my heart, both as a mother and a fellow human being, to even think about it.
    Mari – Escape In A Book recently posted…Memorable Quotes Monday – Cinder by Marissa Meyer.My Profile

  8. Ashley Chattaway

    Love seeing a review wars post! I have to agree with Isabelle – I really enjoyed Delirium! Very entertaining debate ladies!

  9. Sai K

    I haven’t read the books yet, but have been let down by other “dystopian” books, so Kat’s argument makes more sense to me, but we’ll see. Thoroughly enjoyable, though. 😀

  10. Rebecca Hipworth

    Thanks for the giveaway. I haven’t read Delirium yet but it sounds really good. 🙂

  11. Monica

    Thanks so much for the giveaway!! I’ve wanted to red Delirium for so long so this is awesome! 🙂

  12. franchie15

    You ladies are so funny! I agree on both of you on some parts. But I just love Delirium. Sorry, Kat. *wink*

  13. Ashley

    First off I just wanted to let you know how much I adore your book reviews…your goodreads reviews pretty much decide what I read or not. Anyways your post here was also as amazing, plus the pictures are hilarious. Thanks for your reviews, as well as the giveaway! 🙂

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge